
Nurys Mateo is getting the last laugh.
After Johnny “Bananas” Devenanzio recently suggested that Nurys and Horacio Gutiérrez’s public criticism of The Challenge production may have been the reason they weren’t being invited back, Nurys appeared to respond with a confident social media video that many fans interpreted as a direct shot at the seven-time champion. (Ashley’s Reality Roundup)
Nurys Appears to Troll Bananas
In the viral clip, Nurys confidently mocked Bananas’ comments, seemingly reminding fans that she’s officially returning for The Challenge Season 42.
Her playful response quickly spread across social media, with fans praising her for clapping back after Bananas implied her future with the franchise was in jeopardy.
Bananas Questioned Her Return
During a recent episode of his podcast, Bananas argued that openly criticizing MTV and the show’s production team could hurt a competitor’s chances of being cast again. He specifically referenced Nurys and Horacio, suggesting their public complaints may have explained why they weren’t receiving return invitations. (Ashley’s Reality Roundup)
The comments sparked debate throughout the Challenge community, with some agreeing with Bananas’ perspective while others felt he was speaking on behalf of production without actually knowing future casting decisions.
Season 42 Proves Otherwise
Now, Nurys’ return for The Challenge Season 42 appears to tell a different story.
Rather than addressing Bananas directly in an interview, Nurys let her casting announcement do the talking, using humor to celebrate her return and poke fun at the speculation surrounding her future on the show.

Fans on social media quickly pointed out the irony, noting that Bananas questioned whether she’d be invited back only for her to secure a spot on the upcoming season. (Reddit)
Fans React to the Shade
The playful exchange has generated plenty of conversation online, with viewers taking sides between the longtime franchise legend and one of the show’s newer fan favorites.
Some applauded Nurys for embracing the moment with confidence, while others defended Bananas by arguing his original comments were taken out of context. Regardless, the back-and-forth has only added more anticipation for Season 42.
With both Bananas and Nurys returning to the franchise, fans will be watching closely to see if their social media feud carries over once the competition begins.
As The Challenge Season 42 prepares to premiere on August 5th, one thing is certain: Nurys made it clear she’s back—and she isn’t letting the critics have the final word.

Leave a Reply